For this week’s reading, we’re leaving the alien
future for the Victorian past in Jonathan Mayberry’s novelization of the movie The Wolfman. I saw the movie back when
it came out in 2010 with high hopes. But the movie left me feeling rather… meh. I’ve seen worse, but I've seen far
better, and I expected more. When I saw the book on the reading list, my first
thought was that the movie was based on the book. After discovering this wasn't the case, I was hesitant. The movie wasn't anything to write home about, and
the novelization would be the movie in paper form.
I was pleasantly proved wrong. Author Jonathan
Mayberry fleshed out the somewhat flat story of The Wolfman and made it an enjoyable read. Yes, the plot of the
book exactly followed the plot of the movie, but isn't that the point of a
novelization?
Werewolves are some of the classic bad beasties, but
recently—like pretty much all monsters—they've turned into brooding heartthrobs
with washboard abs who aren't evil, just misunderstood. I don’t mind a sexy
werewolf every now and then (and there are some sexy times thrown into the
book), but it’s refreshing to get back to basics. Werewolves represent the most
base, primal, violent urges of mankind that (hopefully) lay dormant in most,
but are exaggerated and acted upon when in the wolf state. They don’t represent,
well, puppies.
Lawrence Talbot, the Wolfman, is a true werewolf,
and unlike the movie, I was better able to get inside his head. While I watched
Benicio Del Toro who played Talbot turn into the Wolfman on screen, I felt Talbot turn into the monster on the
page, and it was a cringe-worthy experience. Every bone in the body broken to
be reshaped, every tooth pushed free by a fresh set of fangs.
Ouch is an understatement.
The Wolfman is his own creature, with no hint of the
man he used to be. Mayberry makes a clear distinction between Lawrence and the
Wolfman by giving them their own POVs and not using their names
interchangeably. While I found myself looking at the monster in the movie to
try to figure out how they did the makeup, I was right there when it was
completely lost to instinct and went on its killing spree when I read the same
scene.
I watched the horror of realization spread over Del
Toro’s face when Talbot understands he’s the monster, but I experienced the
horror of this realization with him as I read. I’ve always been a fan of
werewolves, but never really thought about how terrifying it would be to
completely lose control and commit horrible acts, then later comprehend the
extent of what happened because of that loss of control. Not to mention the
fear of what would happen if control was loss again, but in the presence of a
loved one.
I loved this full access into the monster’s head
that I didn't get while watching the movie. It isn't a werewolf reinvented, but
a werewolf examined as a monster rather than a tortured soul. There is some
tortured soul action, but from Lawrence’s point of view instead of the
Wolfman's. And the reactions to being a werewolf are compared and contrasted
between Lawrence who hates what he is and his maker who fully embraces the monster
within.
Overall, the novelization took the story to the next
level, which the movie failed to achieve. Instead of being just another monster
story, The Wolfman novelization helped the reader to participate in
what it could be like to be a werewolf by engaging the imagination, which isn’t
the most glamorous way to portray these monsters in most books on the shelves.
But this was the first time I've cringed during a werewolf transformation, book
or otherwise, and there’s nothing wrong with that.
I was pleasantly surprised too by how in-depth this was for a novelization. It almost totally worked for me as a standalone work, having not seen the film.
ReplyDeleteI think this novel did a decent job of adding details to the story. I haven't seen the movie, but there were some scenes I could tell were a cinematic sequence transferred to prose, though not to the extent that it became annoying (Halo: The Flood is an adaptation with some tedious scenes where it's painfully obvious it started as a FPS).
ReplyDeleteI agree that it's nice to see a werewolf story where the Wolfman really is an out-of-control monster once it transforms.
Its interesting that you found this so much better than the movie. I agree that things were definitely fleshed out but I still wasn't a big fan. If the movie is that much worse, then I definitely will not be watching it.
ReplyDeleteI made sure I watched the movie after I read the book, before I wrote my post. I really wanted to have the comparison and the full story to work with, which I think is what a movie book does--gives you the rest of the story you don't quite see, and works in tandem with the film.
ReplyDeleteThe terror of losing control is made all the worse because it is inevitable. Then the man must choose between his own survival, and stopping the monster. He can't have both. Even locking yourself away is to allow the chance something terrible will happen. I imagine that was the beginning of the slippery slope Sir John descended. First he allowed the chance evil could happen, then he actively pursued it.
ReplyDelete